U.S. hiring bounced back in November as employers added 227,000 jobs
The November 2024 jobs report showed stronger-than-expected growth, with 227,000 jobs added significantly from October’s 12,000. The unemployment rate edged down to 3.7% from 3.9%. Gains were driven by healthcare, government, and manufacturing sectors, while retail saw declines. Wage growth was solid at 0.4% for the month and 4% year-over-year. This robust report suggests resilience in the labor market, complicating the Federal Reserve’s decision on potential rate cuts as they monitor inflation and employment trends.
The Grievances Of the US Economy By Trump Supporters
It’s a refrain we’ve heard over and over from Trump supporters: “I voted for him because the economy is a mess.” Or the slightly more dramatic cousin: “Bidenomics is destroying America!” These sentiments, amplified across rallies, social media, and Fox News segments, often justify continuing loyalty to Donald Trump.
But then today happens—a new jobs report hits, showing the U.S. economy added a robust number of jobs, unemployment remains low, and wages continue to rise. For a moment, the cognitive dissonance is almost too glaring to ignore. How do you square a narrative of economic despair with solid numbers that suggest the opposite?
Let’s unpack this irony.
The Reality of the Economy
The November jobs report revealed another month of strong labor market performance. The unemployment rate held steady at near-record lows. Job creation continues to outpace expectations, and inflation—while a concern last year—is steadily cooling. Real wages have also been rising, giving workers more purchasing power. By most objective measures, the economy is not falling apart.
Yet, if you only listened to Trump-aligned voices, you’d believe we’re in the midst of the Great Depression 2.0. Political ads, talking points, and memes endlessly hammer home claims of economic catastrophe under President Joe Biden. It’s a potent emotional appeal, even if the data doesn’t support it.
Video: Don't Be Fooled By The DNC—Kamala Harris' Economic Program Is A Recipe For Depression - Forbes - YouTube
Why the Disconnect?
Trumpism thrives on emotional resonance over factual grounding. When supporters say, “The economy is terrible,” they’re not necessarily referring to jobs data or GDP growth. They’re speaking to how they feel—disillusioned, left behind, or anxious about cultural and societal shifts.
This is where the irony deepens. Many economic metrics Trump supporters use to critique Biden—job creation, wage growth, and low unemployment—were pillars of Trump’s self-declared success during his presidency. When those same metrics reflect positively on Biden, they are either ignored or dismissed as “fake news.”
This shift isn’t accidental. Right-wing media and Trump’s messaging machine have created a parallel reality where facts are malleable, and perception is king. To maintain the narrative of decline, any positive economic news is either downplayed or reinterpreted as irrelevant.
The Enormous Challenge of Breaking Through - Democrats Need a New Strategy
Overcoming the deeply ingrained Trump narratives is a monumental task for Democrats and any opposition to Trumpism. These narratives are not just campaign slogans—they’ve been woven into his supporters' cultural and emotional identity. Logic, data, and even lived experience often fail to penetrate the echo chambers where these narratives are cultivated. As a result, traditional strategies like highlighting policy successes or rebutting false claims head-on usually fall flat.
Democrats will need to rethink how they communicate entirely. Breaking through will require facts and compelling stories that connect emotionally and directly to voters’ experiences. This means finding new ways to meet people where they are—on platforms they trust and in language that resonates. It also means grappling with how disinformation spreads and creating innovative strategies to counteract it, from grassroots organizing to leveraging trusted community voices. Without a fresh approach, the disconnect between economic reality and perception will remain, leaving many voters impervious to evidence.
What’s Really at Stake?
This cognitive dissonance isn’t just amusing; it’s dangerous. When voters ignore objective reality, favoring grievance-fueled narratives, it warps democratic accountability. Their actual performance no longer judges leaders but by how effectively they stoke fear and outrage.
For Trump, this is the ultimate irony. His supporters claim to value economic success, yet many remain unmoved by tangible improvements under Biden. This raises the question: Are they really voting based on economic conditions, or is it something else entirely—culture wars, identity politics, or blind loyalty to a personality cult?
The Bottom Line
Today’s jobs report is a reminder that the U.S. economy, while not perfect, is far from the disaster some claim. It’s also a lesson in irony. The same people who voted for Trump because they believed the economy was broken are now confronted with evidence that contradicts their narrative—and yet they persist.
If this isn’t about the economy, then what is it about? And more importantly, how do Democrats reach people entrenched in an alternate reality? These questions demand urgent answers because the battle for truth—and for democracy itself—depends on it.
Share this post